When I was teaching preschool the NAEYC slogan for either that year or the year before was “Play is Children’s Work.”
One of my very first memories is from when we lived in Boston. I guess I was about three, maybe a little younger. Because this was the good old days (at least for a 3-year old living in that suburban Boston neighborhood), I was free to roam around our cul-de-sac. My mom would put me in a handmade bubble suit and tie my hair up in pony tails and set me loose to wander. My best friend, Pamela, lived next door and I would play on her swing set and run into the woods next door (actually a small grove of young birch trees). Her father’s name was Neal and I was sure this was because he would kneel down to play with us.
Across the way lived bratty Elizabeth. She had a metal swingset — the kind where the leg would thump up if you swung too high. One day I climbed up the slide ladder after her and she turned around to try to shove me off. I looked over at the moms chatting on the cement patio and thought about how they had just missed my brush with death.
Up the street was Kimberly — red hair and freckles. She was annoying and bossy but when Pamela was down for her nap or had to go to bed (she had an earlier bed time than the rest of us), Kimberly would do for a playmate.
Anyway, what I most remember about Kimberly is this overcast day when she and I sat down in a mud puddle to play. It was this fabulous, slippery-smooth mud, which held the shapes we made and molded with a satisfying squish. It was the best goddamned mud I have ever known in my 35-years (and for some time after that day, I went looking for mud as good and couldn’t find it). We planted our little bottoms right in the puddle and dove in aided with dixie cups (the little wax-covered paper drinking cups that people sometimes have in bathroom dispensers) and our own eager hands. I was absolutely in bliss. My play (work) was satisfying and interesting. It was challenging (we had to learn how to work with the consistency, we had to understand the limits of the increasingly soggy dixie cups) and on that day Kimberly’s bossy mouth was quiet as she focused on the task at hand.*
Then these two big girls came over. One was Kimberly’s sister. She said, “Oh are you going to get in trouble!” Kimberly looked down at her mud-covered clothes — from head to toe, we were both covered and splattered in mud — and began to cry. I wasn’t a bit worried because I knew that my mother understood the importance of dixie cup mud pies but I was annoyed that Kimberly’s sister came and disrupted our play.
My mom really did understand. The pictures of me that summer show a filthy and smiling 3-year old. My mother always understood the value of whatever I was doing — mud pie making, truck track building, dollhouse creation, stories I wrote, stories I pretended, anything. She took me seriously and she took my interests seriously. When I decided to be a teacher, she helped me write out notes inviting all of the toddlers in the neighborhood to come to my school. When I wanted to be a writer, she let me use her electric typewriter.
Growing up, I believed that what I wanted to do was important even if other people didn’t understand. My mom always understood. I expected work to be interesting and challenging and worth the drudgery to get to the fun. The feeling I had playing in the mud was exactly the same feeling I have now when I’m working on an article or project that interests me. Playing taught me about work.
I think about my mother whenever I talk to Noah about his play. When he grows up, I want him to seek out work that is as interesting, as exciting and as worthwhile as his play is to him now. I never tell him that when he grows up he’ll have to buckle down and get a job because I know if you get the right job, it doesn’t feel like buckling down. Even the petty annoyances of the right job pale next to the times when you’re streaming along deeply caught up in your task. (I think about the drudgery of paperwork and phone calls at shelter and the sheer joy of pulling together a case plan. I think about the boredom of inventory at the deli and the meditative contentment of reordering the cheese case. And now the sheer hell of queries and mundane resource gathering more than makes up for the way it feels when an article is coming together seemingly without effort.)
My mom taught me about work by leaving me free to play without worrying about the mud in my hair or the bath at the end of it. I hope I can do that for my kids.
*One of the best depictions of this kind of satisfying play that I have ever read is Beverly Cleary’s description of Howie and Ramona’s game, brick factory, in Ramona the Brave.
I have two kids and a delightfully odd husband, Brett. My children are Noah (born to us in 1997) and Madison (born to her first mom, Pennie, in 2004 and brought to our family through a domestic, open adoption). They are my inspiration and also the reason I don't get more done around here.
I'm a writer and sometimes I get published, which is a nice thing. I write for joy, I write for money and when I'm very lucky, both things happen at the same time. My work appears in national publications including Yoga Journal, Disney's Family.com, Utne, Wondertime, Brain Child and Salon. Currently I am working on a book about my daughter's adoption and seeking representation for the proposal. I also own Smart Cookie Communications with my husband.
bj
June 21st, 2005 at 12:32 pm
I wonder if the world has really changed so much, or if we remember wrongly (change probably, the world is always changing). I also have strong memories of roaming wild without parental interference, and a world that children created separately from their parents. In India, we actually use to travel between towns, on the bus, by ourselves (with older cousins). In the US, we’d go to the grocery store by ourselves, when we were 5 years old. And, the summers were spent freely wandering the grounds of the student housing complex we lived in.
But, are you able to replicate this for Noah (and Madison)? How does homeschooling play into it? I’ve always thought that homeschooling brings the child into the limits of the family and parental desires. Do you find that not to be the case? Do you find that by homeschooling you can allow Noah his own separate existence?
bj
LisaV
June 21st, 2005 at 1:01 pm
Very nice.
I think of things like this when things that are of little importance to my life, like algebra, calc, trig,etc. and they are being shoved down kid’s throats. I don’t see writing and art and numerous other things that I find valuable being elevated in the same way. I really have to remember to let my girls know their interests are valid and worth pursuing, because society often doesn’t show that in high school and college. I am grateful that I have found a k-8 school that values their “work” that is motivated by their own interests.
LisaV
June 21st, 2005 at 1:10 pm
Do you let Noah roam? I let my kids in bits and pieces and frankly feel no anxiety about it . But I see the disapproval from some of my fellow moms that I let my 11 year old and 7 year old go to the park -2 blocks away- by themselves. I feel like they need some time away from my scrutiny on occassion.
Tiny Coconut
June 21st, 2005 at 1:54 pm
Your post made me smile. This is precisely the sort of childhood my children are enjoying–a cul-de-sac, long stretches of relative freedom, the chance to get bored and use that to create deep, rich fantasy games. It’s when I peek out my front window to watch a gang of more than a dozen kids, ranging in age from 10 to 3, gamboling up and down the street, screaming at the tops of their lungs, getting into scraps and figuring their way out of them…that’s when I somewhat paradoxically feel as if I’m doing my very best parenting.