Here’s my advice: if everyone likes your baby name, don’t use it. That is if having a unique baby name is important to you. See, here everyone is saying that they love Violet, they love flower names and you know what that tells me? Pretty soon kindergartens across American will be literal gardens of little girls.
When we were thinking of names for Noah, we should have known when every single person (besides my father who thought we should name him Vic) said it was a great name. That was the best indicator we could have had that Noah would go through life with the first initial of his last name tacked on at every roll call.
Now my sister, she named her son Flaviano. You can imagine the reactions that got. (We call him Frankie.) Then when she said she was naming her daughter Lucia, half the people she told — specifically the non-Italian half — just looked puzzled. But that was good because here’s the other truth I have to give you about baby names: once the baby’s here, people tend to like the names they didn’t like before.
Flaviano? We were horrifed! Frankie? Barely better! But he is the cutest little meatball of a Frankie you ever did see and now I love that name. (I always liked Lucia so that one wasn’t a hard sell for me.)
Interestingly, in my oddball friendship community, there are no Madisons because my friends eschew trends. Or at least they try to. (Emma’s mother and I often lament the fact that we didn’t realize that Noah and Emma were on the way up when we hit on ‘em for our kids’ names.) But then within this same small crunchy-granola group, where everyone goes to the same co-op, knows the same midwives, and keeps track of the gossip at the two or three acceptable preschools, we have three children named Indigo. And one named Azure.
This demonstrates the truth of my “well received predicts popularity” theory. While the rest of the world may frown on naming a child for a particular shade of blue, among my people this rates applause. Same goes for Atticus. Although Atticus isn’t popular in my immediate circle, we all know various children named Atticus who are growing up on peace bumperstickers and soy.
(I wouldn’t be surprised to meet a child named after grains like Millet or Quinoa at the playground where Noah takes his homeschool classes, but my daughter may be the only Madison sitting in those baby swings.)
To sum up, if originality is important to you — and I’m not saying it should be — go for the name you love that gets the most blank stares or outright grimaces.
I have two kids and a delightfully odd husband, Brett. My children are Noah (born to us in 1997) and Madison (born to her first mom, Pennie, in 2004 and brought to our family through a domestic, open adoption). They are my inspiration and also the reason I don't get more done around here.
I'm a writer and sometimes I get published, which is a nice thing. I write for joy, I write for money and when I'm very lucky, both things happen at the same time. My work appears in national publications including Yoga Journal, Disney's Family.com, Utne, Wondertime, Brain Child and Salon. Currently I am working on a book about my daughter's adoption and seeking representation for the proposal. I also own Smart Cookie Communications with my husband.
Lisa
November 13th, 2004 at 10:57 am
Before Mallory was born in ‘91 we were going to name her Kathryn Elizabeth, for my grandmother. I liked that it was old fashinoned and not all that common. I thought we could call her Kate as a nickname- strong and independent it seemed.
Two weeks before she was born I went to the mall with my mom and sister. Every 2 year old and under was being called “Katie.” I started stopping women with little girls in strollers and asking names-Kate, Katie, Kate, Kathryn, Emily, Emma, Megan. I didn’t know other moms at that point, so this was the first time I realized everyone liked the same names I did.
My sister’s best friend in high school was Mallory. I always liked it because it was unique. And that Mallory was smart, kind and a little bit of a rebel. Perfect combination.
I suggested Mallory Kathryn. Bert went for it. We told no one else. Everyone loved it when we introduced her. There is a random Mallory here and there, but not many.
Aubree was the song by Bread in the 70’s (sad but true), I also thought it was unique. My grandmothers died because they thought of it as a man’s name.
Linley was a character on a wonderful show that was cancelled after one season in the 80’s (A Year In The Life). We told no one, no one her name before she was born. Everyone loves it, but she gets called Lindsey a lot.
Mason’s birthparents named him. Interestingly it’s a name we had said we would use if Mallory were a boy. We like it, its unusual without being made up. We chose a different middle name then they did though. I wanted him to have something from me. He has my husband’s last name, so I gave him the middle name Christopher. Not very unusual huh?
mellowyellow
November 13th, 2004 at 11:27 am
A few years ago here in the UK there was a surge of babies called after australian soap ’stars’ hense my granddaughter class mates are all called Kylie, Dwane etc. The latest craze is uk soaps, the mind boggles… poor kids! Love your blog!
shortnorthmama
November 13th, 2004 at 12:39 pm
Oh, I am living the misery of the suddenly too popular baby name. When we were living in california, it was a not-too uncommon name. But when all our relatives in Ohio looked at us with utter confusion when we told them the name we liked, we took it as a good sign. So we named her the name I liked. Unfortunately at the time we didn’t have cable, because a certain HBO show had a baby with the same name at almost the exact same time. Now there are kids her age everywhere with my daughter’s name. One at the end of our street even.
She also has a Chinese name which is slightly different from her American name. In our toddler chinese class one day, I mentioned what her Chinese name meant. The next week, the mom who had been sitting next to me told me they were going to use my daughter’s chinese name for their new baby, and did I mind? What could I say? But I was very annoyed. The NERVE! It isn’t like it is a common name and it was chosen for her by her grandmother. GET YOUR OWN FRICKEN NAME and don’t copy ours! I have a name reserved for our next daughter and I guard it with my life. I am totally afraid it will become popular in the next two years.
Holly
November 13th, 2004 at 1:47 pm
Ah, that explains a lot. We got completely positive reactions to Logan’s name, and then a year or two later we were fairly embarrassed and disappointed to discover it was in the top 50 names. Top 50, not that common? Well, for one, it’s more common than we wanted, but for another, it varies by region. Logan’s best friend is another Logan. From what I can see from the school newsletters, there are at least 3 Logans in every grade. Sigh.
Dylan, on the other hand, we were about 10 years too late for the Dylan trend and so its not heard often around here anymore. My relatives thought it was downright weird. But his middle name, now nobody has ever reacted positively to that: Archer. So maybe that’s a good name, unlikely to become trendy.
Jen
November 13th, 2004 at 4:08 pm
I’m sorry. I too swooned at the name Noah. Biblical names seem like a good way to ensure that your son will grow up to be hot.
Sorry. That was rude. True, but rude.
brooke
November 13th, 2004 at 5:07 pm
if i ever have a little girl, her name will be harlan. i love that name, and its not too popular.. now, if i have a boy, he’ll be harry.. a popular name, but also the name of my father. dad had it 62 years ago, long before it became the name of a best selling novel..
shannon
November 13th, 2004 at 7:05 pm
I wanted our girl name to be Harriet. There are so many good nineteenth century African American Harriets. But my partner simply would not have it. Even if it’s all-girl triplets, she’s chaffing at Harriet.
And though gender-neutrality is important to us, if a Harriet grew up and wanted to be a boy, she could easily become “Harry.”
Can anyone think of a way to convince a spouse of a name???
Sigh.
Mona
November 13th, 2004 at 8:08 pm
I feel the same way! I don’t think there are many children with my screen name, Macaby. Now I don’t know if I will name my future girl that.
I love my husband’s name, Raven. He and I decided instead of name our girl Addison, we’ll just name one of our cats Addison.
Terri
November 13th, 2004 at 9:40 pm
My sister is my most favorite woman in the world, so I used her middle name, Renee and I wanted to keep something Hispanic about my daughter, seeing how she’s now 3/4 white, so I used Isabel for her first name. I’ve never received so many compliments.
PS - Love your blog!
Moxie
November 14th, 2004 at 7:29 pm
Jen, I feel it’s very important to give a boy a name that preserves the possibility of his being completely and totally hot as an adult. (Of course, I also read the results of some study that claimed that boys whose parents coslept with them until they were 2 had more sex when they were in college than boys who had slept alone in cribs and got really happy thinking my son might be statistically more likely to get botty in college.)
Unfortunately, my husband and I have different ideas of what names are hot.
Cara
November 15th, 2004 at 1:23 am
I love your site and that post made me laugh and feel better about my proposed name for our new baby. We have an Adelaide Zelda (talk about not likely to rocket to the top of the charts!) and I was thinking that Bernadette would be lovely, and go well with Adelaide, (Addy/Bernie! It’s fate!) but everyone I tell gives me the old fish-eye on that one. I don’t really care if the name is popular or not, as long as it’s a good name, so (all evidence to the contrary) I’m not looking for the most unique name on the planet, but I don’t want to feel like I’m consigning my child to Ugly Name Hell while I’m all hopped up on pregnancy hormones. So now when people smile painfully at me when they hear “bernadette”, I will just reflect on your wise words and think that I am blazing trail, not destroying my child’s one shining chance at happiness by not naming her Nicole or something normal like that. By the way, do email me if you think I am, after all, consigning her to Ugly Name Hell. Please think of the children. Thanks.
jen
November 15th, 2004 at 12:22 pm
This is nothing new, either; my mom still swears that in 1973 she knew of no baby girls called Jennifer and was unpleasantly surprised when I started nursery school, like, gee, thanks mom, were you living in a CAVE when you had me? So it’s important to me to give my kids uncommon-but-not-laughable names. Thank heavens for the US census list, since our expected little girl was almost Abigail, and then almost Isabel — both totally unusual for me, both names I looooove, but apparently extremely popular. Whew.